top of page

Tackling Lateral Analysis Challenges for Driven Steel Foundation Piles


A. Introduction

Driven steel foundation piles are widely used in construction for their durability and load-bearing capabilities. When it comes to designing and analyzing these piles for lateral loads, engineers need to employ robust methods to ensure the stability and safety of structures. This article will delve into the tricks and tips for conducting effective lateral pile analysis for driven steel foundation piles, and illustrate how we can perform lateral pile analysis for single piles and groups of driven steel piles in DeepFND – Deep Foundations Design Software.


Lateral Pile Analysis Results - Rectangular cap with driven steel beams in DeepFND

Figure: Lateral pile analysis results – Rectangular cap with driven H piles in DeepFND


B. Challenges in lateral pile analysis for driven steel piles

The use of driven steel piles introduces specific challenges in lateral pile analysis due to the characteristics of the installation method. Let's explore some of these challenges:

Soil Disturbance during Installation:

Driven steel piles are installed by forcefully driving them into the ground. This dynamic installation process can cause soil disturbance around the pile. The altered soil conditions near the pile may lead to variations in soil properties, affecting the accuracy of the lateral pile analysis. It is crucial to account for these changes and consider the potential non-uniformity of the soil profile.

Pile Setup and Relaxation:

Driven piles often experience a phenomenon known as "pile setup" or "relaxation" over time. After initial driving, the pile may undergo changes in its capacity and stiffness due to factors such as pore water pressure dissipation, soil consolidation, and the development of additional friction along the pile shaft. The evolving behavior of the pile over time poses a challenge in accurately predicting its response to lateral loads.

Variability in Pile Driving Resistance:

The resistance encountered during pile driving can vary significantly, even within a single project site. Variability may arise from differences in soil layers, density, and other subsurface conditions. This variability in driving resistance can affect the ultimate lateral capacity of the pile, making it challenging to precisely determine the lateral load-carrying capacity during the analysis phase.

Pile-to-Pile Interaction:

In situations where multiple driven steel piles are closely spaced, the interaction between adjacent piles becomes a critical consideration. The impact of one pile on another can lead to complex soil-structure interaction effects. It is essential to account for pile-to-pile interaction to ensure the accurate prediction of lateral displacements and forces in a pile group.

Dynamic Effects from Pile Driving:

The dynamic nature of pile driving introduces additional complexities. The vibrations and dynamic forces generated during installation can influence the soil response and alter the properties of both the pile and the surrounding soil. Analyzing the dynamic effects of pile driving on the subsequent lateral behavior of the pile requires specialized methods and tools.

Pile Toe Resistance:

Driven steel piles often rely on end-bearing resistance at the pile toe. Accurately predicting the lateral behavior of the pile involves considering the mobilization and distribution of this toe resistance under lateral loads. The interaction between the pile toe and the underlying soil layers must be carefully modeled to capture realistic pile responses.

Nonlinear Behavior of Steel Piles:

Steel piles exhibit nonlinear behavior under lateral loads, especially in the post-yield range. The analysis needs to consider the inelastic behavior of steel and potential plastic deformation. Utilizing appropriate material models that account for the nonlinear response of steel is crucial for accurately predicting the lateral performance of driven steel piles.


Addressing these challenges requires a comprehensive understanding of the driven steel pile installation process, coupled with advanced analytical methods and accurate soil-structure interaction models. Collaboration between geotechnical and structural engineers, along with the use of reliable field monitoring data, can contribute to overcoming these challenges and ensuring the successful design of foundations using driven steel piles under lateral loads.


C. Tackling the driven steel pile installation challenges with DeepFND Software

DeepFND has established itself as the forefront standard in designing and analyzing foundation pile systems. Its intuitive interface empowers users to effortlessly input soil properties, define the structural section of piles, and consider various loads on the pile head. The software excels in performing both axial and lateral pile analyses, utilizing advanced techniques like soil springs and 3D finite element analysis. In addition to analyzing individual piles, DeepFND extends its capabilities to structural and geotechnical design, pile group and pile raft analysis, and even the structural design of pile caps—all within a unified and powerful software suite.

In the following paragraphs, we explore the key parameters essential for a successful lateral pile analysis and how DeepFND serves as an invaluable assistant in this process.

  

- Understand the Basics of Lateral Loads:

Before diving into the analysis, it's crucial to have a solid understanding of lateral loads. Lateral loads can result from wind, seismic activity, or eccentric loading conditions. Recognizing the different sources and magnitudes of lateral loads is fundamental in designing a robust foundation system. DeepFND software allows us to define various axial and lateral load types on the pile head of single piles and on pile caps, allowing the direct application of several load combination load type factors.


Applying different load types on the pile head in DeepFND

Figure: Applying different load types on the pile head in DeepFND


Implemented load combinations in DeepFND

Figure: Implemented load combination factors in DeepFND


- Characterizing Soil Properties:

Accurate characterization of soil properties is critical for a reliable analysis. Conduct thorough geotechnical investigations to determine soil types, shear strength, and other relevant parameters. Utilize this data to establish appropriate soil-pile interaction models in the analysis. DeepFND software implements several estimation tools that allow us to directly estimate soil properties from SPT and CPT records, as well as other soil testing data.


Estimating soil test data from SPT blow counts in DeepFND

Figure: Estimating soil properties from NSPT in DeepFND


- Selecting Appropriate Analysis Methods:

Various methods are available for lateral pile analysis, including simplified methods, p-y curves, and finite element analysis. The choice depends on the project requirements, soil conditions, and the desired level of accuracy. Simplified methods may be suitable for preliminary analysis, while more complex projects may warrant finite element analysis for a detailed assessment.

DeepFND allows us to analyze pile groups and pile rafts with both the soil springs and the 3D finite element analysis approach. This ability allows the user to check the models with different powerful analysis approaches considering full soil-structure interaction, recognize potential issues and overcome complex design challenges.


Lateral pile analysis for a pile group - Soil spring method

Figure: Lateral pile analysis for a pile group in DeepFND – Soil spring method


Soil mass displacements on X direction - DeepFND 3D FEM analysis

Figure: Soil mass displacements on X direction - DeepFND 3D FEM analysis

  

- Developing P-Y Curves:

P-y curves are widely used in lateral pile analysis. These curves describe the lateral soil resistance along the depth of the pile. Proper development of p-y curves requires careful consideration of soil properties and should be based on realistic load-displacement behavior. Numerous models considering Cohesive/cohesionless soil and rock materials are available in DeepFND with suggestions and testing correlation available for the model parameters.


P-Y springs simulating the subsoil

Figure: P-Y springs simulating the subsoil


- Consider Group Effects:

In projects involving multiple piles, consider the group effects on lateral behavior. Piles within a group can interact, influencing the overall response. Group effects should be incorporated into the analysis to ensure the design meets the desired level of safety and performance. A number of options based on strength and/or flexibility factoring of the P-Y curves associated the interacting piles are available in DeepFND


Group effects for adjacent pile in the lateral direction

Figure: Group effects for adjacent pile in the lateral direction


- Time history analysis:

Time history analysis is a sophisticated option capable of accurately capturing wave propagation in the time domain. This option can provide a better insight on a pile group behavior under dynamic loads such as earthquake excitations and machine vibrations in comparison to a more conservative equivalent static representation of the dynamic loads associated. Dynamic loads can be easily introduced in DeepFND in the form of dynamic point loads or boundary earthquake excitations through the software GUI.


Seismic record defined as the analysis time history record in DeepFND

Figure: Seismic record defined as the analysis time history record in DeepFND


- Validation through Field Testing:

Field testing, such as lateral load tests, provides an opportunity to validate the accuracy of the analytical models. Comparing the predicted behavior with actual field performance enhances confidence in the selected analysis methods.

DeepFND allows us to input axial and lateral test data, and directly compare the software estimated lateral displacements and settlements with the results from the pile tests.


Lateral load test & implementation in DeepFND

Figure: Lateral load test & implementation in DeepFND


Pile head displacements – Pushover analysis and lateral load test

Figure : Pile head displacements – Pushover analysis and lateral load test


D. Conclusion

Effectively analyzing driven steel foundation piles for lateral loads is crucial for the structural integrity of a project. By understanding the basics, selecting appropriate methods, characterizing soil properties accurately, and considering various factors such as group effects and dynamic loads, engineers can design foundation systems that meet safety and performance standards. Continuous validation through field testing further ensures the reliability of the analytical models employed in the lateral pile analysis process.

 

Join our Workshop on the design of Deep Foundations!


DeepFND Software - Design of deep foundations and helical piles


Online Deep Foundations & Helical Piles Design Workshop

Learn with PDH!



Comments


SELECTED POSTS: